Source: United States Department of Justice Criminal Division
A federal grand jury in the District of New Jersey returned an indictment yesterday charging a resident of Florida with running a massive operation over many years to traffic in fraudulent and counterfeit Cisco networking equipment with an estimated retail value of over $1 billion.
According to the indictment, Onur Aksoy, aka Ron Aksoy, aka Dave Durden, 38, of Miami, allegedly ran at least 19 companies formed in New Jersey and Florida as well as at least 15 Amazon storefronts, at least 10 eBay storefronts, and multiple other entities (collectively, the “Pro Network Entities”) that imported tens of thousands of fraudulent and counterfeit Cisco networking devices from China and Hong Kong and resold them to customers in the United States and overseas, falsely representing the products as new and genuine. The operation allegedly generated over $100 million in revenue, and Aksoy received millions of dollars for his personal gain.
According to the indictment, the devices the Pro Network Entities imported from China and Hong Kong were typically older, lower-model products, some of which had been sold or discarded, which Chinese counterfeiters then modified to appear to be genuine versions of new, enhanced, and more expensive Cisco devices. As alleged, the Chinese counterfeiters often added pirated Cisco software and unauthorized, low-quality, or unreliable components – including components to circumvent technological measures added by Cisco to the software to check for software license compliance and to authenticate the hardware. Finally, to make the devices appear new, genuine, high-quality, and factory-sealed by Cisco, the Chinese counterfeiters allegedly added counterfeited Cisco labels, stickers, boxes, documentation, packaging, and other materials.
The fraudulent and counterfeit products sold by the Pro Network Entities suffered from numerous performance, functionality, and safety problems. Often, they would simply fail or otherwise malfunction, causing significant damage to their users’ networks and operations – in some cases, costing users tens of thousands of dollars. Customers of Aksoy’s fraudulent and counterfeit devices included hospitals, schools, government agencies, and the military.
As set forth in the indictment, between 2014 and 2022, Customs and Border Protection (CBP) seized approximately 180 shipments of counterfeit Cisco devices being shipped to the Pro Network Entities from China and Hong Kong. In response to some of these seizures, Aksoy allegedly falsely submitted official paperwork to CBP under the alias “Dave Durden,” an identity that he used to communicate with Chinese co-conspirators. To try to avoid CBP scrutiny, Chinese co-conspirators allegedly broke the shipments up into smaller parcels and shipped them on different days, and Aksoy used at least two fake delivery addresses in Ohio. After CBP seized a shipment of counterfeit Cisco products to Aksoy and the Pro Network Entities and sent a seizure notice, Aksoy allegedly often continued to order counterfeit Cisco products from the same supplier.
According to the indictment, between 2014 and 2019, Cisco sent seven letters to Aksoy asking him to cease and desist his trafficking of counterfeit goods. Aksoy allegedly responded to at least two of these letters by causing his attorney to provide Cisco with forged documents. In July 2021, agents executed a search warrant at Aksoy’s warehouse and seized 1,156 counterfeit Cisco devices with a retail value of over $7 million.
Aksoy is charged with one count of conspiracy to traffic in counterfeit goods and to commit mail and wire fraud; three counts of mail fraud; four counts of wire fraud; and three counts of trafficking in counterfeit goods. Aksoy was charged by a criminal complaint filed in New Jersey on June 29 and was arrested in Miami the same day.
Assistant Attorney General Kenneth A. Polite, Jr. of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division; Attorney for the United States Vikas Khanna of the District of New Jersey; Acting Special Agent in Charge Eddy Wang of the Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) Los Angeles Field Office; Special Agent in Charge Bryan Denny of the U.S. Department of Defense, Defense Criminal Investigative Service (DCIS) Western Field Office; Special Agent in Charge Floyd Martinez of the General Services Administration Office of Inspector General (GSA-OIG), Southeast and Caribbean Division; Special Agent in Charge Peter Tolentino of the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS), Economic Crimes Field Office; Special Agent in Charge Anthony Salisbury of the HSI Miami Field Office; and Special Agent in Charge Jason Molina of the HSI Newark Field Office made the announcement today.
The CBP Electronics Center of Excellence; the CBP Los Angeles National Targeting and Analysis Center; and the CBP Office of Trade, Regulatory Audit and Agency Advisory Services, Miami Field Office provided valuable assistance.
If you believe you are a victim of Aksoy or the Pro Network Entities, please visit www.justice.gov/largecases or https://edit.justice.gov/usao-nj/united-states-v-onur-aksoy-pro-network for more information.
The Pro Network Entities include at least the following:
|
Pro Network Companies |
Approximate Month and Year of Formation |
State of Formation |
|
Pro Network LLC |
August 2013 |
New Jersey |
|
Netech Solutions LLC |
November 2016 |
Florida |
|
Target Network Solutions LLC |
January 2017 |
Florida |
|
Easy Network LLC |
April 2017 |
New Jersey |
|
ACE NETUS LLC (aka Ace Network) |
April 2017 |
New Jersey |
|
My Network Dealer LLC |
April 2017 |
New Jersey |
|
1701 Doral LLC |
May 2017 |
New Jersey |
|
Maytech Trading LLC |
August 2017 |
Florida |
|
NFD Trading LLC |
September 2017 |
Florida |
|
Kenet Solutions LLC |
September 2017 |
Florida |
|
Team Tech Global LLC |
January 2018 |
New Jersey |
|
Tenek Trading LLC |
January 2018 |
Florida |
|
The Network Gears LLC |
February 2018 |
Florida |
|
All Networking Solutions LLC (aka All Network) |
April 2018 |
Florida |
|
San Network LLC |
October 2018 |
Florida |
|
Pro Network US Inc. |
January 2019 |
Florida |
|
Jms Tek LLC |
August 2019 |
Florida |
|
Renewed Equipment LLC |
August 2021 |
Florida |
|
Pro Ship US LLC |
August 2021 |
Florida |
|
Pro Network Amazon Storefronts |
Approximate Date of Earliest Known Activity |
|
Albus Trade Hub |
January 2014 |
|
EasyNetworkUS |
March 2014 |
|
Get Better Trade |
July 2015 |
|
Mercadeal |
February 2017 |
|
Netech Solutions |
February 2018 |
|
Netkco LLC |
September 2014 |
|
NFD Trading LLC |
January 2018 |
|
Palm Network Solutions |
June 2017 |
|
Renewed Equip |
August 2017 |
|
Servtaur |
August 2019 |
|
Smart Network |
July 2017 |
|
SOS Tech Trade |
August 2017 |
|
Target-Solutions |
September 2020 |
|
TeamTech Global |
March 2016 |
|
TradeOrigin US |
August 2015 |
|
Pro Network eBay Storefronts |
Approximate Date of Earliest Known Activity |
|
connectwus |
March 2014 |
|
futuretechneeds |
July 2017 |
|
getbettertrade |
July 2017 |
|
getontrade |
April 2016 |
|
maytechtradingllc |
October 2017 |
|
netechsolutions |
April 2017 |
|
netkco |
September 2014 |
|
nfdtrading |
February 2018 |
|
smartnetworkusa |
January 2014 |
|
tenektradingllc |
May 2018 |
HSI, DCIS, GSA-OIG, NCIS, and CBP are investigating the case.
Senior Counsel Matthew A. Lamberti of the Criminal Division’s Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section and Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrew M. Trombly and Senior Trial Counsel Barbara Ward of the District of New Jersey are prosecuting the case.
An indictment is merely an allegation, and all defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law.